Silksong’s Perfect 100 Metacritic Debut: A Histori
Hollow Knight: Silksong hit a perfect 100 on Metacritic, briefly becoming the highest-rated game ever. A historic indie Metroidvania debut.
In the annals of gaming history, few moments have sparked as much buzz as the debut of Hollow Knight: Silksong on Metacritic. When the long-awaited sequel finally launched on September 4, 2025, it didn’t just meet expectations—it shattered them, at least initially. As of its first few reviews, Silksong achieved a perfect score of 100 on Metacritic, making it the highest-rated game of all time on the aggregator, dethroning the legendary The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, which sits at 99. 
Now, in 2026, that perfect score may have settled as more reviews poured in, but the achievement remains a feather in Team Cherry’s cap. It’s not every day a game—especially an indie Metroidvania—shoots to the top of the charts. Let’s dive into the details of this monumental debut and what it means for the gaming landscape.
The Perfect Score That Shook the Gaming World
At the time of its debut, Silksong had only four critic reviews on Metacritic, but that was enough to give it a flawless 100. While it’s likely the score will drop as more reviews come in (and indeed, it may have by now), the fact that it ever reached 100 is a testament to its quality. For context, Ocarina of Time has long been considered untouchable with its 99, so Silksong briefly stood alone at the summit. 
Game
Metacritic Critic Score
Year
Hollow Knight: Silksong
100 (at debut)
2025
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
99
1998
Other top-rated games
97-98
Various
But the critic score isn’t the only story. The user score for Silksong stood at an impressive 8.7 based on 851 ratings, showing that fans were largely on board. Interestingly, the highest user score of all time belongs to another 2025 release, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. So both 2025 games made history in different ways. It’s a banner year for gaming, folks! 
A Six-Year Wait That Paid Off
Hollow Knight: Silksong was in active development since 2019, and Team Cherry’s reason for the long delay was simple: they kept having fun adding more content. That dedication shows. The game has been praised for its smooth platforming, iconic challenge, and the beloved protagonist Hornet. However, the difficulty was a sticking point for some, leading to the game’s first update that lowered the difficulty. That move sparked debate, but it also showed Team Cherry’s willingness to listen to players.
The game’s release was a bit of a surprise—the release date was only revealed two weeks prior, on September 4. That didn’t stop it from becoming a smash hit. Despite some review bombing over its Chinese localization, Silksong has remained a critical and commercial darling.
The Dark Side: Review Bombing and Difficulty Debates
No launch is without its hiccups. Silksong faced a wave of review bombing over its Chinese localization, which some players felt was subpar. This led to a flurry of negative user reviews, but it didn’t stop the game from achieving a high user score overall. Meanwhile, the game’s difficulty was a hot-button issue. Many fans loved the challenge, but others found it too punishing. Team Cherry responded with an update that lowered the difficulty, a move that was both praised and criticized. It’s a classic case of “you can’t please everyone,” but Team Cherry handled it with grace.
What Critics Are Saying
While we only have a handful of critic reviews to go on, the early consensus is overwhelmingly positive. Here’s a quick rundown of what reviewers are praising:
-
Smooth platforming: The movement feels fluid and responsive. -
Iconic challenge: The game offers a tough but fair experience. -
Art and atmosphere: The world of Pharloom is stunning. -
Music and sound design: A hauntingly beautiful soundtrack.
And the criticisms? Mostly about the difficulty spike and the localization issues. But overall, it’s a winner.
The Metacritic Milestone
Let’s put this into perspective. Metacritic has been aggregating reviews since 1999, and in that time, only a handful of games have ever reached a 99 or above. Ocarina of Time has been the gold standard for decades. For Silksong to debut with a 100—even with only four reviews—is like hitting a grand slam in your first at-bat. It may not